- 2026
- Brady Bushman- Dotham- Wallace JC
- Alec Brehm- Marieta College
- Terrance Todd- Capitol University
- De’Vion Gipson- Wilmington College
- 2025
- Andrew Visconti- University of Southern Mississippi
- Nate Iden- Eastern Kentucky University
- Elliot Davis- Thomas Moore College
- David Haas- Grinnell College
- Chase Cox- Muskingum College
- Tommy Jewell- Illinois Institute of Technology
- Anthony Robinson- Dotham- Wallace JC
- Trey Hummel- Chipola JC
- Drew Johnson- State College of Florida
- Ben Brandon- Patrick Henry CC
- Colton Cannon- Olney Central College
- Dylan McIntyre- San Jacinto CC
- Josh Caudill- SW Tennessee St CC
- 2024
- Mark Rutherford- University of Dayton
- David Hagen- University of West Virginia
- Charlie Dieruf- Miami University (OH)
- Lucas Davids- Lake Erie College/Lincoln Trail JC
- Dylan Ruhe- Tiffin University
- Luke Laufman- Wittenburg University
- Logan Walpole Heidelberg University
- Nicholas Sedam- Pensacola State College
- Anthony Sedam- Pensacola State College
- Gabe Vojak- McKendree University
- 2023
- Jack Smith- Marshall University
- Jake Murphy- University of Louisville
- Jackson Heimbuch- Belmont Abbey
- Kody Kelly- Palm Beach Atlantic
- Ryan Cathey- Tusculum
- Finn Ellis- University of Charleston (WV)
- Brayden Cheeseman- Heidelberg University
- Will Ramsey- Earlham College
- Conner Roberts- Heidelberg University
- Colin Combs- Olivet Nazarene
- Jackson Wing- Walbash Valley College
- Brayden Stewart- SW Tennessee St
- 2022
- Nate Earley- Florida Southwestern/U of Louisille/USF
- Kayden Campbell- U of Louisville/Georgia Tech
- Bryce Amos- University of West Virginia
- Nolan Smoot- University of Louisville
- Cody Schneider- Limestone
- Michael Napolitano- Catholic University
- Kuyper Lashutka- Denison
- Oscar Welsh- IU Southeast
- Sam Duvall- Pasco-Hernando College
- Simeon Graves Jr- Weatherford College
CINCY DURHAM BULLS 